I have been thinking a lot recently about home
educating. This has mostly been because
my 11 year old ds taught himself to read about 4 months ago. This is one of the fears of many of my fellow
home edders who take the autonomous route of education where we don’t actively
teach our children but facilitate them learning what they want to learn when
they want to learn it.. It is well known
that an average self-taught reader will be anything between 3 and 14 years old
but most seem to start showing an interest around 9 if they haven’t before
that. 11 and a half seems old!!! I don’t know why we have this obsession with
reading and that is what got me to thinking.
Why Maths and English? As an
English nation we all know English: we all speak it. So why after we have been taught to read and
write does it go any further than that? We abstract the ability to read from all the
reasons we need to know how to read. Most
of the other subjects taught at school involve the ability to read, write and
sometimes speak English. So why force
children to read books if they don’t want to read books? Why abstract the ability to read, write and
speak as part of natural life and have a separate subject that involves skills
that you don’t need to be a valuable member of society? You wouldn't force a child to dance when they
don’t want to dance especially not to GCSE level even though I reckon the
ability to know how to move your body and finding enjoyment from it is a way
more valuable skill than the sedentary activity of reading fiction.
Again with maths.
Mental arithmetic I totally get.
A useful skill to have although I don’t believe you need that skill at
the age of 6 or even any time before you are going to need to use it say in a
shopping scenario. Financial acuity on
the other hand a wholeheartedly worthwhile skill that needs to be learnt before
taking out your first credit card, loan, mortgage, etc. The area of a circle however is a fact that
anyone can look up on the internet. It
isn't a necessary fact to teach 9 year olds: the ability to regurgitate that
area = pi * radius ^2 does not 'maketh the man.' I know that
Martin Lewis
has managed to get financial skills into the curriculum but I have a feeling
that many children will have been put off actually listening to this vital
information by the way that numeracy and maths is taught in the earlier
years. Again most children learn to
count before going to school – how is it that we turn the beautiful simplicity
of maths into something so sterile and to many so confusing and/or boring?
The sad contradiction here is that kids love to learn. Try and get a child to stop doing
something they are absorbed in and you know what I mean. My children will forget to eat, forget to go
to the toilet and forget to go to bed when they are absorbed in what they are
doing. This is when the
deep level learning occurs: the learning that stays with you years later. And that learning can occur through random
play, social interactions, or as Archimedes discovered whilst taking a bath or
as Newton discovered sitting under an apple tree. The shallow learning of facts for the sake of
it however tend to fade because they are not backed by the ability or passion
of wanting to learn those facts at that time.
And that is my main reason for home educating my children. Passion:
the human right that every person has to learn something/anything when
they are either ready and able and/or have a desire to do so. And by ready and able, I mean when mental/physically/emotionally
capable.
My ds learnt to read because he was ready and able. Once he realised that his brain could cope
with deciphering the squiggles into words and that he had the vocabulary from
all the bedtime stories my husband had read to him and all the conversations he
had had, he started reading. Just like
that. He was mentally capable. If you meet him now a few months later you
wouldn't know that he hasn't been reading since he was 5. His passion for wanting to read and his
capacity to do it led to him reading and he did it all himself which has given
him a sense of worth that he would never have if he had been in school.
My dd on the other hand has been reading since she was
5, again self-taught. Her brain could decipher squiggles but telling the time
(which ds could do at age 4) was a different matter for her. Numbers didn't make as much sense as letters
to her when she was younger. Her mental
arithmetic and number skills have been learnt as part of life, through playing
card games and going to the shop with her brother.
She recently learnt to tell the time because it helped her know when her
school friends were getting home from school.
She found it difficult but persevered because she wanted to be able to
do it and her passion saw her through.
I am hoping that dd’s passion for reading and ds’s
passion for computing and maths will help them when it comes time to get their
English and Maths GCSEs (if that is still what they are by then.) You may have realised that I don’t feel that
those 2 subjects are any more important than others and in fact I feel that
they are stunningly less important especially in the way they are taught at
school. My children will probably jump
through those hoops and a lesson in pointless fact regurgitating will be learnt
and I feel that is a shame.
This isn't what I thought I would write about when
discussing home ed. I thought I would be
citing Ken Robinson videos and hack-schooling (I’ll add those at the bottom
just in case you are interested LOL).
Instead I would love for everyone to empower their children because they are amazing beings. Those
little babies that learnt to walk, talk, build towers, learn to use the toilet,
etc. did so because they wanted to be like us.
They don’t need to be taught facts for the sake of learning them so that
they can be tested and judged. If we
have to teach them anything then at least let’s teach them real stuff that will
be useful all through their lives. We
have loads of creative, passionate, resourceful teachers out there and instead
of using their talents we squash them into teaching abstracted subjects and
learning is fast becoming synonymous with test passing. Let’s set our children and teachers free to
explore real subjects in a creative and stimulating way and let’s give teachers
the freedom to know when a child is ready, willing and able to absorb those
facts and adjust their role accordingly.
So although I believe that all learning should be
self-directed I thought I would put together a national curriculum just to show
how things could be different if we had a government who actually wanted to
adhere to their law about education being about an “education suitable to age,
aptitude and ability”.
Anatomy and movement – I reckon everybody should know how
their bodies work, how to move them correctly and look after them - breathing
skills, meditation, swimming, climbing, cycling, etc. Let's also give our children a healthy appreciation for how real bodies look, not
photo-shopped bodies like
here
Nutrition, cooking and sustainability – what we put in our
bodies affects how they work, learning to make healthy meals from natural ingredients
is vital to our survival. Looking at
where food comes from, learning to grow it, learning wild food foraging, learning
about
permaculture and other sustainable activities, etc.
Philosophy – the ability to form an argument and not take
everything on face value is a vital skill.
So much of what is in the newspapers or that we are bombarded with via
the TV needs to be taken with a pinch of salt.
Let’s give our children the skills to want to check the facts and not
believe everything they are shown, told.
(Watch
this video about one guys attack on the daily mail to see what our newspapers are really doing to us)
Mental arithmetic and financial skills – so you don’t get
short-changed at a shop or fleeced by a loans company, knowing about how statistics
really work and how they are skewed to serve many purposes would also be really
useful.
Empathy and non-violent communication (NVC) type skills – let’s
teach our children to disassociate a person from their behaviour so that no-one
is shamed and judged as bad because of the things they have done, forgiveness,
acceptance of others, self-worth, etc. Watch
this video to see how prejudice really works, watch
this one for how teachers have the power to affect how children perceive prejudice and watch
this one to see how forgiveness can really change lives for the better.
I am sure there are other important areas but these were just off the top of my head. However subjects like history, geography, pure maths, applied
maths, English literature, etc. can be left for those who are passionate about
them.
Here is one of the many brilliant Ken Robinson talks about education. This one is extra brilliant because of the added animation. Every one in the world should watch this video!!!
Here are some interesting videos/pages and books about education:
Here is a poem I wrote about my issues with school and our testing culture in this country:
Human Experience is not a test
Can you assess my state of happiness?
Can you score it out of five?
Can you really pass or fail a test
That tells if you are truly alive?
Is joy a quantifiable trait?
Can you plot it on a graph?
Do you score a special funny point
Every time you laugh?
Is empathy a transferable skill?
Can others give feedback?
Telling you if there are any traits
In which they think you lack?
I don't think you can pass an exam
In love or contemplation
I don't think you can get an NVQ
In passion or in meditation
Hope cannot be learnt from a book
Grace cannot be easily taught
Peace cannot be summed up in lesson
Just because you think it ought
You cannot have a kindness target
That everyone must reach
The attainment of gentleness
Is not something you can teach
The fruits of spirit andsoul
Need space and time to grow
They cannot be cultivated in league tables
Or seen in "tell and show"
Spirit cannot be marked and scored
Even if you wanted to
Because human experience is not an exam
ONLY YOU can A* you